Gamecommunity =GCHQ=
http://forum.gamecommunity.co.uk:8080/

LCD or Plasma
http://forum.gamecommunity.co.uk:8080/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=48833
Page 1 of 2

Author:  Alex Quim=GCHQ= [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 12:21 am ]
Post subject:  LCD or Plasma

Just curious as to which is best out of plasma or LCD tv's in terms of:

1. display (price dependent i pressume)
2. Life expectancy of tv (have heard neither last as long as a CRT, could be bull tho)

Is there anything else to consider when choosing one?

Author:  Mike=GCHQ= [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 1:07 am ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

i shall have words with my brother and dad as they've been researching this just recently.and found out quite a lot....

from top of my head off what they've been saying recently.. if i recall right..

top of the range is about 2k at the moment.. i think

1080 progressive is only for console's / pc's perhaps..since they will never broadcast in that resolution given the amount of bandwith required....the difference between 1080i and 1080p is very very slight and you will not notice it ...

the bigger the picture ...the more u get a blur .. especially in motion sports like football...so it might be better to get like 32 - 39 inch instead of a much bigger one..especially considering that if you're watching SD picture... it gets stretched and distorted which looks baaad...imo..

plasma's give a softer picture...

whether you choose plasma or LCD is a matter of preference ..equally as good..

Author:  Chips=GCHQ= [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 1:16 am ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

I think there's a difference in power drain though... one draws more power, and I think it's plasma.

Should be fairly easy to find out with google though.

Author:  andy_m8 [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 1:24 am ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

it really is a matter of personal preference, with me I love plasma - fast response times, proper balcks and perfect colour reproduction are a must - which plasma is the king of

you only have to look at one of the pioneer sets to see why :)

Author:  Mike=GCHQ= [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 1:26 am ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

before you buy...give us the model of the t.v.

my dad is signed up to a 30 day trial of an independent assessor of products.. they review them and tell you all about it .. compared to other ones on the market

Author:  Mike=GCHQ= [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 12:02 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

Quote:
Plasma's are generally heavier than LCD. But both need a decent wall and bracket if being wall mounted.

Screen burn can occur also by channel logo's in the corners of the screen.
Some manufacturers shift the picture on bootup by a few pixels to minimize sharp edges being to burnt on the screen by logos.

Recent LCD's response times have come down dramatically, therefore they display less of the trails on fast moving objects (ie a moving football has far less comet trails / blur behind it when moving across the screen) Contrast ratio of LCD has improved so they now equal / out perform plasma's.
Viewing angles of LCD screen are still less than plasma but these have improved.

Price of LCD's is now generally lower than plasma too until you get really large

Like Jules pointed out on a small screen got for LCD ( personally I would stretch that out to anything under 50")

Just remember.. When shopping for an large screen TV dont be taken in by a demo in just one shop. Look at the same unit in different places.
I saw a LG 50" plasma the other day in a shop, the demo was a Beyonce BlueRay DVD, with huge surround sound system blasting out.... It looked awesome (so did she.. )... The competition in the shop next door had the same set but with a standard feed and the sound coming from the puny internal speakers... The whole out look of the unit was totally different.. However they had another set in a made up "demo lounge" that has sound proofing laid out how nobody (well most of us) can have their own lounge. Once again the output from the set was awesome.. Largely due to the HD input and quality surround system they were showing..

When looking at any set LCD or Plasma, make sure you get to see the performance in various input forms. ie HD, standard satellite, internal tuner analogue and digital if the set has both..

Get the volume up and see how the speakers cope with higher volumes. (shops never have the volumes set as high as a user would at home, unless they use separate system) I turned up a Technika unit in Tesco the other day, before the volume hit 50% the speakers were rattling )

Play with all functions on the set too before buying... Some shops aint got a clue on how to set a picture up. All they do is turn on and press auto adjust...

How easy it is selling sets in this false scenario fashion, only do you find the true when value you then get it home to be dissapointed with the performance..

Look around, get demos, go away get prices off the net, go back to the shops and see if they will price match....
__________________




Quote:
Plasma Tvs Are The Largest Tvs Atm Right Up 105" If You Really Wont One That Big .
If Its A Small Tv You Want Then Stick To Lcd ,they Cant Be Produced Beyond 42" But A Plasma Cant Be Made Below A 37"
Plasma Are Supposed To Eat Electricity ....not True ,an Lcd And Plasma The Same Size Will Use Comparable Similar Amounts .
Plasma Do Not Suffer With Motion Blur Like The Lcd
Both Suffer With Screen Burn If You Are Not Carefull.
Plasma If Set Up Correctly Produces The Better Picture

Author:  nicey=GCHQ= [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 1:05 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

spent 3/4 months deciding...
eventually went with lcd sony x series 40 inch...

no buzz..which some plasmas have...
no heat..which plasmas give...
more effient energy use....

if it had to be plasma.... i'd go for pioneer...
alternative lcd's..id go for toshiba....
phillips look great with the ambient light..but i beleive they are hardware iffy.


o btw..it pays to have a good hunt around... some give free 5 years warrenty on sonys... some charge 400 quid for it...

Author:  happyslappy [ Sun Jan 13, 2008 1:36 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

bravia ftw
you can see the diff between 1080i and 1080p but you need 50" + to notice
http://www.avforums.com is your friend

Author:  LeBeourfCurtaine [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 1:04 am ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

Plasmas a few years ago had a very short life expectancy - 5 years tops. Nowadays 10 years I think.

Author:  gemma=GCHQ= [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 2:18 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

Quote:
If Its A Small Tv You Want Then Stick To Lcd ,they Cant Be Produced Beyond 42" But A Plasma Cant Be Made Below A 37"


Ahem, I used to own a 32" plasma now I own a 46" LCD go figure.

Author:  andy_m8 [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 4:44 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

gmar=GCHQ= wrote:
Ahem, I used to own a 32" plasma now I own a 46" LCD go figure.


Then your 32" wasnt HD :wink: each pixel on a plasma tv is like a small glass vial containing gas, its just impossible to fit 1280 x 720 into 32" :grin:

Author:  Magoo=GCHQ= [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 5:21 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

I just had a 37" LCD and was amazed how good the picture is on blu day.

amazing....

Author:  gemma=GCHQ= [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 8:09 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

andy_m8 wrote:
gmar=GCHQ= wrote:
Ahem, I used to own a 32" plasma now I own a 46" LCD go figure.


Then your 32" wasnt HD :wink: each pixel on a plasma tv is like a small glass vial containing gas, its just impossible to fit 1280 x 720 into 32" :grin:


Correct there were no HD tvs when I bought it. Sorry if I was being misleading.

Author:  Alex Quim=GCHQ= [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 10:23 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

Thanks guys :thumbr: , gonna take nicey's example an ponder over my options for a while.

Author:  nicey=GCHQ= [ Tue Jan 15, 2008 10:52 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: LCD or Plasma

DEPENDING ON HOW MUCH...THIS IS A PRETTY GOOD BUY @ THE MO...


http://www.robertwhyteltd.co.uk/
http://www.robertwhyteltd.co.uk/Sites/i ... %20DAVIS10

I have the home cinema unit..and i love it..thats @ 400 quid alone....
so it make the tele.... 600 quidish... cheapest i can find elsewhere is 800+ plus for telel
john lewis is the only one i find with a free 5 year guarentee...no sound system....

http://www.johnlewis.com/Technology/Tel ... urce=12021
http://www.ukprices.com/televisions//co ... MAodGXEnvw

Page 1 of 2 All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/